Due to an overwhelming response, both publicly on the blog and private emails, I've decided to do a follow up. I want to address a few comments/thoughts that were shared with me. I love that this post has generated so many diverse thoughts and this post, by no means is an exhaustive epistle on the issue. I have my own perspective on it, and I am not so arrogant to think that I can write in an unbiased fashion.
Ready? Here we go...
Jesus and the Upside Down Kingdom:
2 Greatest Commandments: Love God and Love Others (my paraphrase)
In Jesus' ministry, He took all of what was the norm and flipped it upside down. He made God accessible to everyone. He made it simple. He welcomed everyone to the table, to His teachings, to His Life. Men, women and children. That was Jesus.
Church as a "Club":
We have all probably had a moment in our lives where we wanted to be part of a club/group/clique that for some unknown reason we were excluded from. Remember the pain? The anger? The wondering...why aren't I welcome here?
My own personal fear is that church as we know it, has become a club. A club with secret dress codes and passwords.
How much better if church was synonymous with community, welcome, hospitality and love. Simplistic? Idealistic? Perhaps, but when Jesus summed up the whole Old Testament with the 2 Great Commandments, seems to me that He was doing the same.
Jesus as the Head of the Church:
Yep. I agree. Jesus is crazy, stupid in love with the church...no matter how much we screw it up.
Culture and Context:
One of the things that I detest the most in theological arguments is when culture is relevant through the ages for certain issues but not others. One of these issues for me is the whole women in leadership issue. Somehow, we can still cling to the text that cites the woman should be "silent" in church, but throw out texts around jewellery, short hair on women and head coverings.
I'll be the first to admit that Paul's writings seem conflicting at times. At one point he speaks of women praying and prophesying, then in the next breath saying they should be silent. He has several women deacons such as Lydia and Priscilla and then says women should ask questions of their husbands at home.
Here's a thought, in reading the whole bible as an overarching, never-ending story, we can see the ways God has worked in the world. God is fluid, adaptable, Creator. He is not limited by our ways, but rather works within for His good. Yes, the world before was patriarchal, women were limited in their public roles. But God wove in women of faith and wisdom to take up prominent roles in the history of Christianity.
The Giftedness of All:
I think most people nowadays would agree that both men and women are equals; created that way by God. Then why then would God calls us to 2 deeply different roles? Why would one role be of leadership and the other submission ? Especially if men and women are not only of equal status and dignity before God but in every other way as well?
Consider a successful computer business. Profits are high, the brand is popular with consumers, staff loved the company and executives worked as a team and everyone loves the boss. The boss is smart, funny, makes wise decisions, is a great team builder and know the business inside out. The boss is also a strong person of faith, who is not afraid to let that be known, but is warm and welcoming to all. Wouldn't you want this person in leadership in your church?
Perhaps. But the "problem" is that the boss is a woman. Somehow all the gifts that make her a success in the world gets stripped away the minute she enters a church. They are not longer acknowledged. In my humble opinion, that doesn't make sense.
Phew! There was a lot more tossed about in the comments...but I think that is all for me right now. Comments welcomed. Please show grace when responding to others that might have a different view.
***If you are at all interested in reading a fairly balanced view on Gender as a whole, I suggest "Finally Feminist" by John Stackhouse. (Don't let the title fool you)